No Man Was Given the Title of Pastor And How Man-Made Hierarchy Has Distorted Christ’s Gift of Shepherding His Church

When did the gift of shepherding God’s people become a position of power over them?
And when did the Church—the ekklēsia, the Body of Christ—begin operating more like a worldly business than God’s Kingdom?
Today, many congregations revolve around a single senior pastor who holds the highest human authority, makes the final decisions, and directs other leaders beneath him. Yet the New Testament presents a different pattern: multiple elders serving together, diverse spiritual gifts working throughout the Body, and Jesus Christ as the only Head of His Body.
Not one individual in Scripture is given the formal title “Pastor.” So where did our modern model originate, and does it reflect the leadership Jesus taught?
1. THE WORD “PASTOR” APPEARS ONLY ONCE AS A MINISTRY GIFT
The English word pastor comes from Latin and means shepherd. The Greek noun is poimēn (ποιμήν), meaning one who tends, guides, feeds, and protects sheep. It appears only once specifically identifying shepherds as a ministry gift to the Church. Ephesians 4:11–12 describes Christ giving apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors and teachers to equip every believer for ministry and build up His Body.
Notice three important truths:
First, “pastors” is plural—poimenas (ποιμένας), meaning shepherds.
Second, shepherds are listed alongside other ministry gifts, not elevated above them.
Third, their purpose is to equip the saints for ministry, not monopolize ministry themselves.
Understand that it is a spiritual gift to the Body of Christ given to serve the Body, not to establish one person as its highest authority. The Body is to create more leaders that disciple, not followers for themselves.
2. ELDERS, OVERSEERS, AND SHEPHERDS: WHAT DOES THE GREEK SAY?
The New Testament connects three Greek terms describing congregational leadership.
Presbyteros (πρεσβύτερος): Elder—someone entrusted with spiritual maturity and responsibility.
Episkopos (ἐπίσκοπος): Overseer—someone who watches over and cares for the congregation.
Poimainō (ποιμαίνω): To shepherd—to tend, feed, guide, and spiritually protect God’s people.
In Acts 20:17, 28, Paul summons the elders of Ephesus and tells these same individuals that the Holy Spirit made them overseers to shepherd God’s Church.
Peter likewise addresses the elders, instructing them to shepherd God’s flock without domineering over others (1 Peter 5:1–3).
Then Peter identifies Jesus as the Chief Shepherd—archipoimēn (ἀρχιποίμην)—in 1 Peter 5:4.
Peter called himself a fellow elder, not a supreme pastor. Jesus alone is the Chief Shepherd.
3. THE APOSTLES APPOINTED MULTIPLE ELDERS, NOT ONE SENIOR PASTOR
The apostolic pattern of congregational leadership repeatedly emphasizes plurality.
Acts 14:23 — Paul and Barnabas appointed elders in every church.
Acts 20:17, 28 — Ephesus had multiple elders serving as overseers and shepherds.
Titus 1:5 — Titus was instructed to appoint elders in every town.
Philippians 1:1 — Paul greeted the overseers and deacons in Philippi.
James 5:14 — Believers were instructed to call the elders of the church.
Acts 15:6, 22 — Apostles and elders in Jerusalem deliberated together.
Although certain individuals exercised considerable influence, Scripture does not identify them as solitary senior pastors exercising exclusive authority.
God never asked us to follow the world, He said the opposite: "Don't copy the behavior or customs of this world". God's intention was never one solo leader or pastor. That's why the apostles repeatedly appoint multiple elders. Plural leadership provides shared wisdom, accountability, protection from pride, and the opportunity for different spiritual gifts to operate together.
4. GOD’S DESIGN IS SHARED LEADERSHIP, NOT WORLDLY HIERARCHY
Jesus explicitly contrasted Kingdom leadership with worldly domination.
“Not so with you.” — Matthew 20:26 (NIV)
In Matthew 20:25–28, Jesus warned His disciples against imitating rulers who lord authority over others. Instead, He taught them to serve.
Peter reinforced this instruction in 1 Peter 5:3, using the Greek word katakyrieuontes, meaning to dominate or lord authority over others. Leadership in God’s Kingdom is not about being above others. It is about serving alongside them.
In the business world, a chief executive delegates responsibilities while retaining ultimate decision-making authority. But the Church functions opposite of the business world, and its shepherds are not spiritual CEOs or Presidents, although many like to give themselves those titles.
The church demonstrates a different approach in Acts 15. When a major doctrinal dispute arose, apostles and elders gathered, discussed, listened, examined Scripture, and reached a shared judgment.
Their letter declared:
“It seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us...” — Acts 15:28 (NIV)
Different leaders contributed different strengths and spiritual gifts. They did not simply wait for one individual to dictate God’s will. Their shared responsibility and provided accountability. The point is to ask the Holy Spirit because His sheep listen to His voice, He knows them and they follow Him (John 10:27). Psalm 32:8 promises that God will instruct, teach, and watch over the way a person should go. God does, not pastors, not husbands, God does. There is no voting or delegating.
A board that merely approves whatever one senior pastor wants is not genuine accountability. No leader is beneath another IN Christ. We are all called to lead as His Body.
5. NO ONE PERSON POSSESSES EVERY SPIRITUAL GIFT
Paul explains in 1 Corinthians 12:4–27 that the Holy Spirit distributes different gifts throughout Christ’s Body. The Greek word charismata means grace-gifts—abilities graciously given by God. One member may possess wisdom, another teaching, another discernment, another administration, and another exceptional pastoral care.
If no individual possesses every spiritual gift, why would we organize the Church as though one person’s wisdom and authority must supersede everyone else’s?
Paul declares that the Body is made up of many members, not one (1 Corinthians 12:14–21).
Healthy leadership requires humility—recognizing when another member possesses the knowledge, gift, experience, or anointing needed for a particular situation. This is not simply delegating tasks from the top down. It is mutually working together, yielding to one another’s strengths, acknowledging weaknesses, and allowing the Holy Spirit to work through His entire Body, male and female.
That is how we crucify pride and arrogance and learn to lead in love.
6. THE QUALIFICATIONS OF AN OVERSEER: CHARACTER, NOT STATUS
In 1 Timothy 3:1, Paul writes:
“If anyone aspires to the office of overseer, he desires a noble task.” (ESV)
The original Greek begins with Ei tis (Εἴ τις)—“If anyone,” not “if any man.” The NRSVUE likewise translates this as “whoever aspires to the office of bishop.” The Greek does not contain separate masculine personal pronouns such as “he” or “his” in this instance, English translation added those. Greek masculine grammatical forms do not automatically establish a male-only requirement.
Even the phrase “husband of one wife” (1 Timothy 3:2) is translated differently in the NRSVUE as “married only once.” This demonstrates that a male-only interpretation is not the only way the passage has been understood.
Notice that Paul uses episkopos (overseer), not poimēn (pastor). Neither 1 Timothy 3 nor Titus 1 mentions the title “pastor” or “senior pastor.” Instead, Paul describes the character expected of overseers and elders.
The ecclesia is not a building of worship on Sunday, it is the living, breathing body of Christ. It is describing the character of the ecclesia leaders, whether an elder or an overseer, whether male or female. There are many females named as ministers and leaders in the Bible both in the Old and New Testament.
According to 1 Timothy 3:1–7 and Titus 1:5–9, they must demonstrate integrity, maturity, self-control, gentleness, hospitality, faithfulness, humility, and sound teaching—not arrogance, greed, violence, or domineering behavior.
Paul emphasizes Christlike character, not superior status, prestigious titles, commanding personalities, or the right to control others.
The Holy Spirit distributes His gifts according to His will (1 Corinthians 12:11), not according to gender or human titles.
Christ alone is the Head of His Body the Church. Those entrusted with overseeing His people are called to serve His Body, not rule over it (Matthew 20:25–28).
7. SCRIPTURE CONDEMNS LEADERS WHO LOVE BEING FIRST
In 3 John 1:9–10, John confronts Diotrephes, a man who loved to have first place and refused to welcome other believers and leaders.
The Greek word philoprōteuōn means loving to be first or seeking preeminence.
Diotrephes demonstrated the danger of prideful leadership—rejecting others, exercising control, and refusing correction.
What happens when a leader becomes so attached to being first that other Spirit-gifted members are treated as threats rather than fellow servants?
Jesus warned us to recognize people by their fruit (Matthew 7:16–20). A spiritual title does not prove maturity. Character does. And a congregation becomes vulnerable when one individual is placed beyond meaningful accountability.
Shared leadership with different giftings helps protect against moral failure, burnout, isolation, and the misuse of authority. It also requires transparency and accountability to the congregation—not merely leaders protecting one another.
8. THE BODY HAS ONE HEAD—JESUS CHRIST
“And he is the head of the body, the church...” — Colossians 1:18 (NIV)
Ephesians 4:15–16 describes the entire Body growing from Christ as every part contributes.
Every member belongs to Christ. Every spiritual gift comes from Him. We are all called to lead as His Body and every leader remains accountable to Him. This does not eliminate leadership or oversight. It places those responsibilities under Christ and within the shared life of His Body.
Ephesians 5:21 calls believers to submit to one another out of reverence for Christ. Leaders should demonstrate that same mutual humility.
No human leader should become the functional head of a Body that already has a Head. Taking God’s place is called Idolatry and Blasphemy.
FINAL THOUGHT: THE CHURCH DOES NOT NEED ANOTHER KING
Jesus never called His followers to build personal kingdoms or corporations, compete for titles, or establish personal empires with franchises. He called them to serve, make disciples, and create other leaders to disciples and advance His Kingdom.
The apostles appointed multiple elders male and female. The Holy Spirit distributed different gifts. Jesus prohibited domineering leadership. And Scripture consistently identifies Christ as the only Head of His Church.
The problem is shepherds mostly pointing to themselves instead of Jesus, maybe they forget that the sheep belong to Him. They like to talk about Him without reflecting Him.
The Church does not need a CEO, president, or earthly king. It already has the King of kings and Lord of lords.
And it does not need leaders competing to be first. It needs Spirit-filled servants who recognize Christ working through one another. Leaders IN Christ do nothing from selfish ambition or empty conceit, but in humility regard others as better than themselves. They look not to their own interests but to the interest of others with the mind of Christ. (Philippians 2:3-5).
It is time to stop building the Church around fog machines - entertainment, titles, gender-based agendas, and worldly hierarchies—and return to one Body, many members, diverse gifts, male and female made in His image, mutual accountability, shared leadership, and one glorious Head: Jesus Christ.
The question is not, “Who gets to be in charge?” The question is, “Will we allow Jesus to be?”
“Where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom.” — 2 Corinthians 3:17 (NIV)
Please share so others may know the truth that sets free.
To know more about Leadership inside the ecclesia, get my book:
Well Done Good and Faithful Church Leader? Solutions to the Leadership Crisis in the Church
This book is an expanded version from my thesis when I did my master's in leadership ministries
Or read my blog Hierarchy Is For a Godless World
At Mighty4Jesus.com under Blogs or Manuals for books
Be free to be mighty for Jesus
In freedom and might,
Jeannette
Facebook: Let My Women Go




Comments